The proposed destruction of the iconic Stillorgan Orchard pub and its renowned thatched roof, located in the southern part of Dublin, has elicited quite a reaction of dismay and shock from locals, as conveyed by community representatives.
Robert Etchingham and John Martin, the proprietors of the establishment, submitted an application to the Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown County Council, requesting approval for the pub’s demolition and the construction of two apartment blocks comprising a total of 41 flats. Mr Etchingham heads Belgrave Capital Ireland, which sought planning permission backed by ‘consent’ from Mr Martin. Both individuals constitute the exclusive directorship of The Strand Gastro Pubs – the owner of the site.
Centrally located next to Stillorgan Shopping Centre and directly facing the erstwhile Blake’s Restaurant and Esmonde Motors venues, the Stillorgan Orchard is a gastropub that has been serving the community for over a century.
The proprietors aim to construct two blocks of apartments, measuring six and four storeys respectively. The front apartment building is expected to house 33 apartments, alongside a restaurant and a retail outlet on the ground floor. The rear block is set to contain eight flats. Landscape gardening is planned beneath a first-floor podium that will link the two blocks, the tallest of which is set to rise to a height of 19.8m.
The proposal suggests modifications to the existing vehicular access from The Hill and plans for public open spaces, a car park with 27 spaces, bicycle storage for 58 cycles, bin storage, landscaping, internal access routes, and lighting.
Fine Gael councillor Maeve O’Connell confirmed on Tuesday that she had been contacted by multiple concerned locals about the plans. “There’s significant disappointment in the area, a sentiment I too echo. On one hand, people are hurting about losing an integral part of their heritage represented by the thatched roof. On the other, the concern is around a new large-scale development sprouting up right at the heart of the village,” she commented.
O’Connell added, “This location is a symbol of our cultural heritage. We’re risking the village atmosphere by transforming it into a mini town centre. There must be consensus on our vision for the area rather than allowing unplanned changes to alter the character of the community.”
Councillor Deirdre Donnelly, who is independent, expressed that the pub and the surrounding cottages contribute to Stillorgan’s charming village ambiance. “While I believe it’s crucial for us to construct houses and flats to help individuals secure their own property, it’s quite regrettable that a beautiful and traditional thatched building is set to be destroyed,” she noted. She also commented on the sadness of losing the unique village character in Stillorgan. The area could emulate towns like Blackrock, Dundrum, Cabinteely, and Foxrock, which are all thriving with a strong village-like atmosphere.
The local populace was “astounded” about these plans, according to Councillor John Kennedy of Fine Gael, not only within Stillorgan, but also in neighbouring locales. “Community members appreciate the pub’s contribution to the area’s character. Hence, they are deeply saddened by the news. The pub enhances the village’s sense of community. The residents have witnessed considerable alterations in Stillorgan’s design courtesy of the incoming developments, and this pub is a cherished social hub for these inhabitants.” Kennedy stated.
Despite efforts to reach out to the pub owners on Tuesday, they were unavailable for any communications.