Regardless of how you decide to view it, the proverbial elephant inevitably lingers in the room. Rory McIlroy’s quest for a fifth Major title remains enigmatic, with no clear expectation of when it would be accomplished. For a decade now, this has been his story. A continuous stream of days, weeks, and years all morphing into an ongoing barren period of vexation.
Rory McIlroy, hailing from Northern Ireland, has yet another shot at the title at the upcoming US Open at Pinehurst No.2. This will be his 37th Major championship since his triumphant win at his fourth career Major in the 2014 US PGA Championship.
Of course, having the stature of a world-renowned player, McIlroy has had his fair share of opportunities. To cite a few examples, the previous year’s US Open at the Los Angeles Country Club could be regarded as a missed opportunity, as could the 150th Open at St Andrews in 2022. Among others, too.
The US Open organised by the USGA aims to scrutinise every conceivable aspect of a player’s golf skills. Pinehurst introduces an entirely distinctive set of challenges. The venue lacks the heavy rough routinely associated with standard US Open locations; however, this doesn’t necessarily imply a simpler contest. On the contrary, the fast and firm condition of the No.2 course demands a novel approach, strategic reasoning, and enhanced shot execution.
McIlroy will once again strive to prove his worth. Although he doesn’t grapple with the same recurring issues that plague him at Augusta in the pursuit of a green jacket, he is running out of time.
Having been attempting for 10 years, unsuccessfully to date, to secure his fifth Major – with Seve Ballesteros (5) and Nick Faldo (6) still surpassing him in the league of modern European Major winners – McIlroy cannot escape the psychological impact accumulated over the years.
His sole US Open victory came about at Congressional in 2011, marking his initial Major triumph. Following three successive unsuccessful attempts from 2016 to 2018, McIlroy has consistently ranked in the top 10 for the past four years, with his closest attempt being a second-place finish to Wyndham Clark in Los Angeles the previous year.
Paul McGinley harbours no doubt that McIlroy stands as a superior golf player today compared to the time he won the Wannamaker Trophy a decade ago. Nevertheless, apprehensions persist within him, regarding the mental tribulations associated with McIlroy’s game, especially under the intensely firm and quick grounds at Pinehurst.
In McGinley’s view, McIlroy may have developed a more capable approach to his game than he ever had, yet the Pinehurst conditions may not be his ideal ground for exuberance. In spite of this, his game has shown improvements under these conditions, as his fabulous chipping comes to his aid. Pinehurst should offer him an edge due to its chipping-heavy and run-off prone areas drawing upon his enhanced abilities. His long hitting talks notwithstanding, his chipping prowess makes him one of the giants in the game, coupled with commendable putting skills.
McGinley often insists McIlroy is a superior player to his former self, boasting no glaring weaknesses in his game now. His wedge play competence is unquestionable and from distances as far as 100 yards, he stands amongst the best players. However, to triumph in Major tournaments again, he must overcome a significant psychological obstacle, regarded as the quintessential hurdle by McGinley.
He likens this scenario to Real Madrid’s Champions League final, owing their success to their inherent belief in victory. Ancelotti too is a part of this innate winning spirit. Currently, McIlroy lacks this indomitable confidence in Major tournaments. Long gaps of ten years without victories tend to breed doubt and this he considers as the biggest barrier for McIlroy.
McIlroy has previously shared his ambition to surpass Ballesteros and Faldo on the Major honour roll. It is one of his defining career objectives, a crucial part of his legacy.
McGinley, who has transitioned from being a Sky Sports and Golf Channel pundit to a strategic advisor for Luke Donald’s Ryder Cup team in anticipation of the 2025 match at Bethpage, is firmly convinced of McIlroy’s mental resilience, evidenced by his outside performances in the Majors.
McGinley emphasised that it’s certainly not the case that Rory is mentally fragile, rather quite the opposite. When you take into consideration his accomplishments over the past decade, ever since his last Major championship victory, it’s extraordinary and unparalleled. There’s nobody in the same league.
Without a doubt, McGinley believes that Rory stands head and shoulders above all others players in this present age, by a significant margin. It doesn’t imply that Rory suffers from any form of mental frailty. However, the failure to achieve in Major championships in the past decade has instilled an inescapable uncertainty. Everyone is well aware of this, including Rory. It’s not because of a lack of determination, courage, or talent.
Nonetheless, each year, the uncertainty grows, reinforced by the fact that he hasn’t yet managed to clinch another major victory. Naturally, this emotion manifests in all of us as humans.
The responsibility of finding the solution rests solely with McIlroy. He needs to secure another Major victory, surpassing great players like Ballesteros and Faldo in the process.
McGinley suggests that if he manages to break his dry spell with a win, this could potentially open the floodgates, just like when a footballer scores a goal after a long drought. Validation via victory can only dissolve the lingering doubt, as he operates in the real world. When people point out his decade-long Major drought, Rory’s responds with acknowledgement – He’s well aware of the fact.
Nevertheless, should he clinch another Major, it would serve as a massive confidence boost and McGinley believes more victories would follow swiftly. For McGinley, Rory remains unrivalled in his generation.
Listen to more insights on our podcast, Inside Politics.