Tensions regarding asylum seeker housing have once again taken centre stage, following disturbing events in the northern Dublin suburb of Coolock this week. Ongoing protests had been taking place for several months at the intended disruption spot, a vacant factory on Malahide Road set aside to accommodate temporary protection applicants. Things took a turn for the worse when the authorities intervened to displace the protest camp and ready the site for its imminent role. The abhorrent violence that followed resulted in 200 gardaí being deployed and a series of confrontations throughout the nearby vicinity. Public Order units were attacked with fireworks, bottles and canisters as they tried to mitigate the disorder.
This recent upheaval prompts renewed discussions about policy and strategy, as governmental bodies strive to manage the significant upturn in temporary protection applications. Some local political figures in Coolock suggest lack of adequate community consultation added fuel to the fire, although it’s uncertain whether consultations would have deterred the initial demonstrations, let alone this week’s clashes.
What is evident, however, is that social media platforms are being used to stoke local worries by spreading misinformation and disinformation. Far-right proponents are successfully capitalising on these circumstances. There’s a notable need to challenge and rectify these negative influences, alongside addressing the prevalent belief that poorer regions are shouldering an unfair burden regarding new asylum centres.
The State carries both a lawful and ethical duty to house those seeking refuge on its land – a duty which currently remains unfulfilled. It’s also authorised to decide on the sites of the accommodation. Over 30 major properties have reportedly been listed as potential future sites for immigrant housing by the Government. To naively believe that this will not result in similar instances should the plans move forward is unwise.
The pressure the state apparatus is facing due to the refugee accommodation crisis became evident this week due to the conflict between the Garda Representative Association and Justice Minister Helen McEntee. The disagreement was on the subject of whether the security measures taken in Coolock were sufficient or if they put the gardaí in danger. Additionally, there are claims from within the government suggesting that certain offices, especially the Office of Public Works, have not been fulfilling their duties in this sector. Regrettably, the ongoing crisis response seems more segmented than it ought to be, with an all-encompassing government approach needed on various matters, from application processes to establishing new centres. Despite pleas for quick-fix solutions, this dilemma will undoubtedly continue to be an overwhelming task for the current government and future ones.