A surge in business tax income has sparked a governmental argument regarding expenditure, with the Minister for Public Expenditure, Paschal Donohoe, resisting demands from his Cabinet colleagues to raise the National Development Plan’s budget by over €17 billion.
Mr Donohoe decided to allocate €2.25 billion from unexpected corporate tax profits for new investment spending in 2024-2026. However, other Cabinet members have requested almost seven times this amount.
The discussions have stalemated for weeks, with ministerial pleas piling up for the financing of a raft of new projects, as the Coalition braces itself for a general election in the forthcoming year.
While several proposals indicate an uplift in inflation effects on the budget of current projects, the Department of Public Expenditure stated that the biggest factor was requests for “additionality” within the development plan.
Requests include those from Green leader and Minister for Transport Eamon Ryan for significant additional fundings for the BusConnects programme. These requests have sparked pointed inquiries from fellow Cabinet members regarding future road fundings.
Minister for Education Norma Foley is seeking funds to fill a noticeable financial shortfall in the school construction scheme, which has seen some projects halted or paused.
Almost all Cabinet members have reportedly submitted high bids, with Minister for Housing Darragh O’Brien advocating for an escalation of construction and Minister for Arts Catherine Martin requesting money to remodel the present Abbey Theatre site.
Mr Donohoe’s department responded to queries saying, “As anticipated, the demands from all sectors will outstrip the funds available and negotiations are aiming at making agreements with each sector to allow essential projects and programmes to start and finish within the period of 2024 to 2026.”
Following extensive meetings this week with ministers, Mr Donohoe is aiming to conclude the negotiations by Easter. The talks have been characterised as being ‘quite challenging’, with one participant noting Mr Donohoe’s firm stance against an extension of the development plan.
Cabinet members are showing little sign of concession as they strive to incorporate new capital projects into the national plan’s subsequent phase, expected to be a crucial aspect of each Coalition party’s election strategy.
A minister reportedly said, “The money being sought is multiple times more than what is available.”
The discussion surrounding the allocation of €250 million, derived from “windfall” taxes, to the 2024 budget is ongoing, in addition to the current €13 billion government expenditure on education, healthcare, and infrastructure as part of the development plan. Plans for 2025 and 2026 include the possibility of assigning €750 million and €1.25 billion, respectively.
The complexity of the 2024-2026 negotiations is exacerbated by potential impacts on future discussions around National Development Plan projects for the decade to come, slated for the early parts of summer.
Politicians facing upcoming elections are keen to secure funding immediately for long-term initiatives commencing in 2024-2026, aiming to incorporate them into the revised development plan extending up to 2030.
With a surge in tax revenues resulting in capital funding reaching unprecedented levels, establishing priorities for the application of these funds is turning out to be a contentious issue, due to the competing demands relating to investing in health, housing, education, transport, among numerous other sectors.
An individual from the Coalition who is participating in the discussions noted that altering the fiscal baseline through the national development plan is quite delicate as it gives the Opposition a benchmark to respond to.
According to the Department of Public Expenditure, due to capacity constraints within the economy, the funds “will be directed towards projects” that are ready for progression in 2025 and 2026. This implies an analysis of which sectors have efficiently utilized the allocations from the National Development Plan in the past few years and demonstrated a reliable delivery track record.
– For the latest dialogue and analysis, tune into our Inside Politics Podcast.
– Activate push notifications to receive the best news, analysis and comments directly to your mobile.
– Stay informed with The Irish Times on WhatsApp.